Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- test:css2.1:invalid [2011/01/28 11:45] – arronei
+++ test:css2.1:invalid [2011/02/03 12:14] – tests updated, sort fantasai
@@ Line 3: / Line 3: @@
 The CSS2.1 Test Suite results are tracked by the submission of formal implementation reports and from the data in the test suite harness. [add links]
-This page tracks tests that have been reported as invalid.
+This page tracks tests that have been reported as invalid. The tests have all been fixed, and need verification.
-  * <del>background-bg-pos-205</del> - It's up to the UA whether to scroll the <p /> tag at the bottom. change the test to p{ margin:2em;margin-top:0; }.
-  * <del>bidi-005</del> - email thread: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2010Dec/0097.html
-  * <del>bidi-006</del> - make spec undefined.
-  * <del>bidi-007</del> - make spec undefined.
-  * <del>bidi-008</del> - make spec undefined.
-  * <del>bidi-010</del> - make spec undefined.
-  * <del>block-in-inline-relpos-002</del> - [[http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2011Jan/0100.html|proposal from dbaron]]
-  * <del>floats-wrap-bfc-006b</del> - Move test to CSS3
-  * <del>floats-wrap-bfc-006c</del> - move test to CSS3
-  * <del>font-family-rule-002 - email thread: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2010Oct/0263.html</del> - updated for RC5
-  * <del>forced-page-breaks-000</del> - These are OK, they contain CSS3 semantics, but it's not being tested.
-  * <del>forced-page-breaks-001</del> - These are OK, they contain CSS3 semantics, but it's not being tested.
-  * <del>list-style-position-004</del> - Correct the pass condition and the flag to say MAY
-  * <del>page-break-after-010</del> - Elika to re-write
-  * <del>page-break-before-003</del> - CSS3 semantics, but do not impact the test result. OK to leave.
-  * <del>page-break-before-005</del> - CSS3 semantics, but do not impact the test result. OK to leave.
-  * <del>page-break-before-020</del> - test is OK
-  * <del>page-breaks-101</del> - assert needs to be updated by Elika.
-  * <del>page-container-004</del> - Test already changed to may. OK.
-  * <del>page-grammar-001</del> - Let's fix the assertion text a bit to make them less confusing.
-  * <del>page-grammar-002</del> - Let's fix the assertion text a bit to make them less confusing. Title is incorrect (testing both before and after). Elika to do.
-  * <del>rtl-linebreak</del> - should add a negative reference without a border (because the invalidity is that the reference doesn't detect the WebKit failure) - [[http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2011Jan/0101.html|done by dbaron]]
-  * <del>text-decoration-087</del> - test needs to be corrected and split into 2 as well as reworded to clarify the test (needs to change because inline should NOT be underlined). Webkit and FF need to fix their implementations. Opera has an additional bug they will need to address as well.
-  * <del>z-index-020</del> - outlines can validly be drawn on 2 (maybe 3?) different layers, and this test requires them to be drawn onto one particular layer
 ==== Updated but need review ====
@@ Line 48: / Line 23: @@
   * padding-top-036
   * padding-top-047
+These tests were split into ###a and ###b variants (see http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2010Dec/0097.html):
+  * bidi-005
+  * bidi-006
+  * bidi-007
+  * bidi-008
+  * bidi-009
+  * bidi-010
+This test was a) corrected and b) split. Webkit and FF need to fix their implementations. Opera has an additional bug they will need to address as well.
+  * text-decoration-087 - Test corrected and split into 087 and 089.
+These tests received various fixes:
+  * background-bg-pos-205 - It's up to the UA whether to scroll the <p /> tag at the bottom. change the test to p{ margin:2em;margin-top:0; }.
+  * block-in-inline-relpos-002 - [[http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2011Jan/0100.html|proposal from dbaron]], [[http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2011Feb/0009.html|test fixed]]
+  * font-family-rule-002 - email thread: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2010Oct/0263.html</del> - updated for RC5
+  * page-grammar-001 - Updated to be less confusing.
+  * page-grammar-002 - Updated to be less confusing.
+  * rtl-linebreak - add a negative reference without a border (because the invalidity is that the reference doesn't detect the WebKit failure) - [[http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-css-testsuite/2011Jan/0101.html|done by dbaron]]
+  * z-index-020 - outlines can validly be drawn on 2 (maybe 3?) different layers, and this test requires them to be drawn onto one particular layer. Updated.
+==== Deferred to CSS3 ====
+  * floats-wrap-bfc-006b - Move test to CSS3
+  * floats-wrap-bfc-006c - move test to CSS3
 ==== No edits necessary ====
 I did not update these cases because there are no pixel rounding issues in the cases. 25.4mm is equal to 96px.
   * padding-bottom-050
@@ Line 61: / Line 62: @@
+These tests had no change or just metadata updates:
+  * forced-page-breaks-000 - CSS3 semantics, but do not impact the test result. OK to leave.
+  * forced-page-breaks-001 - CSS3 semantics, but do not impact the test result. OK to leave.
+  * page-break-after-010 - CSS3 semantics, but do not impact the test result. OK to leave.
+  * page-break-before-003 - CSS3 semantics, but do not impact the test result. OK to leave.
+  * page-break-before-005 - CSS3 semantics, but do not impact the test result. OK to leave.
+  * page-break-before-020 - Test is OK
+These tests received metadata updates, but no substantive changes:
+  * list-style-position-004 - Flagged as MAY.
+  * page-breaks-101 - Assert updated. OK.
+  * page-container-004 - Flagged as may. OK.